Few teen dramas have sparked as much emotional divide as The Summer I Turned Pretty. This TV show about Belly’s coming of age journey is set in Cousins Beach where Belly Conklin decides between two brothers Jeremiah and Conrad Fisher, who each tug at Belly’s heart in different ways.  

Jeremiah is the golden retriever of Cousins Beach. He is loyal, fun loving, and open with his emotions. He brings lightness to Belly’s summer, the kind of love that feels effortless and safe. At the end of season two Belly decides to attend Finch College to be with Jeremiah. However, Jeremiah’s true colors start to show when he cheats on Belly while on a short break. This rift causes Belly to question if Jeremiah is really her forever partner. 

Then there’s Conrad, brooding on the surface but endlessly caring, he’s the boy Belly has loved for years, even when it hurt. Though he often shields his feelings behind sarcastic remarks or distant stares, his connection with Belly runs deeper than words. Conrad proves his worthiness by being husband material. He cooks, cleans, and is working hard to become a doctor. Team Conrad is the ultimate long game.  

In the end, The Summer I Turned Pretty isn’t just a beachy love triangle, it’s growing up and learning what love really means. Jeremiah offers safety in what she knows, and Conrad offers mystery and something more. Fans defend their teams like best friends in a group chat, but the beauty of the story is that Belly doesn’t just choose between two boys, she chooses who she’s becoming. Whether you’re Team Jellyfish or Team Bonrad, one thing’s for sure, no summer has ever felt quite this pretty.